organic ice cream is made with organic milk from cows that obtain at least 30% of their diet from pasture. … Many organic brands choose to use organic cane sugar rather than other sugar substitutes, which results in an all-around better flavor that’s also free of synthetic pesticides and fertilizers. Since it is made with organically cultivated ingredients, organic ice cream is very healthy. Milk is the key ingredient used in its preparation, and it comes from naturally fed cows. All the agents and preservatives added to the ingredients when preparing organic ice cream during production are natural.